Tuesday 31 October 2023

PLATEAU: BREAKING: TRIBUNAL STILL NAILS PDP OVER LACK OF STRUCTURE. DISMISSES AMB. G. Y. GOTOM’S PETITION AGAINST SEN. DIKET PLANG

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

The National/State Houses of Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal has dismissed Petition No: EPT/PL/SEN/06/2023, which was filed by Amb. G. Y. Gotom and his party, the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), challenging the election of the Plateau Central Senatorial District election conducted by INEC on 25th February, 2023, and the  victory of Sen. Diket Plang and the All Progressives Congress (APC), for lack of locus.

The Judgment of the Tribunal delivered yesterday by Hon. Justice A. Elekwa, held that, the Plateau State chapter of the PDP cannot sponsor a candidate for any election, as long as, it is still in disobedience to Court Orders, which had directed it to organize a fresh Congress for the party in the state.

Hon. Justice Elekwa said, “Sponsorship is different from Nomination. What the Respondents are challenging is the PDP’s qualification to Sponsor and not the Nomination of its candidate (Gotom).

The Tribunal also held that the Petitioners were unable to substantiate their allegations of noncompliance as they just dumped documents on the Tribunal without calling witnesses to testify on them.

Secondly, the Petitioners were also unable to prove their allegations of over-voting as the Four (4) witnesses they called to testify, told the Tribunal that there was no over-voting when they were confronted with the same results by Counsels to the Respondents.

According to the Tribunal, “Even the issue of alteration and manipulation were not proven as the documents tendered though had some cancellations on it, they were readable”.

The Tribunal held that Prof. Dabi had no powers to cancel election results from Kanam Local Government Area of Plateau State, as he is not one of the persons empowered by Law to do so.

Adding that, the Committee that reviewed the election of Plateau Central District must have considered the results of the IRev and reached a conclusion, since the results produced from the IRev and tendered are legible and acceptable like the others also tendered.

The Tribunal held that from the calculations made, Sen. Diket Plang scored the majority of the Lawful votes cast at the election for Plateau Central Senatorial District and therefore his return as declared by INEC is affirmed.

Monday 30 October 2023

PLATEAU: PLANNED PROTEST AGAINST TRIBUNAL/COURT OF APPEAL JUDGMENTS EXPOSED

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

A secret plan by some group of aggrieved politicians in Plateau State to protest over the Judgments of the Tribunal Panels that sat in Jos, the Plateau State capital, and the affirmation of these Judgments by the Court of Appeal Abuja Division has been exposed.

The exposure of the plan has attracted the attention of the media in the state as it is inflicting tension and fear among residents, especially in areas in the state where the proposed protest may take place.

REALITY gathered that, if the protest would hold, major highways leading in and out of the state may be blocked by the protesters.

MORE ON THIS, COMING….

 

PLATEAU RE-RUN: PDP WILL NOT BE ON THE BALLOT! HON. BITURS KAZE INSISTS

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

The crisis over who leads the Plateau State chapter of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) seems not to have an end in sight despite the chain of effects the conflict has had on the chapter.

The struggle for the Chairmanship seat in issue has continually been that of the elders in the chapter in favour of Hon. Bitrus Kaze or Hon. Chris Hassan, with Sen. Gen. J. T. Useni (Rtd) on one side and Sen. Jonah David Jang on the other.

You would recall that the Court of Appeal last week Friday, had reaffirmed that the Plateau State chapter of the PDP has no structure and that all the candidates that contested on the Platform of the party in the state, stood for election as “Independent Candidates”.

Reacting to the Judgment in a political program on Tincity FM 104.3, monitored yesterday by this paper in Jos, Hon. Bitrus Kaze in whose favour the Plateau State High Court had directed the chapter to conduct a fresh election from Ward, Local Governments to State in accordance to the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria, 1999 (as amended) and the party’s Constitution and Guidelines for such election, opined that the chapter would not be in the ballot for the rerun if the orders of the court are not still obeyed.

He said, “PDP will not be on the ballot for the Rerun elections until another congress takes place. This is because the Plateau State chapter of the PDP has no Structure!”

Adding that, “I warned PDP on radio stations and in social media handles severally, but PDP has a very strong Propaganda machine that keeps deceiving the masses.

“Plateau state must not be controlled by an individual or group of people. They must give us what we want and not decide for the masses of the state”.

TO BE CONTINUED…

 

PLATEAU RE-RUN: WASTING VOTES, VOTERS’ APATHY, EXISTING PDP INTERNAL CRISIS ALL GOOD FOR APC, AMB. GIWA, AND RT. HON. BABA HASSAN’S VICTORIES--PUNDITS

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

The major contending parties in Plateau State since the commencement of the 2023 general elections in Plateau State, have been the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) and the All Progressives Congress.

You would recall that, during the era of the former administration in the state led by Sen. Jonah David Jang, the APC was the strong opposition Party, but with the change of baton, the APC led Rt. Hon. Simon Bako Lalong, saw the PDP becoming the major opposition in the state.

However, in the 2023 general election conducted in the state by INEC, the ruling APC was further displaced by the PDP and hence their candidate, Caleb Mutfwang (Esq) emerged as Governor. The PDP also went a distance also to occupy 15 seats in the State House of Assembly and also won two of the Senatorial seats.

This also does not include its dominance of the victories of the seats of Plateau State in the House of Representatives.

Although legally speaking this stride is beginning to dwindle owing to the Judgments coming out of the Judiciary owing to Petitions filed by the APC and its candidates who challenged the victories of the PDP and its candidates.

The latest is the Rerun election ordered for Jos-North/Bassa Federal Constituency of Plateau State and that of the Plateau North Senatorial District seat by the Court of Appeal in the petitions filed by APC, Rt. Hon. Baba Hassan and Amb. Chris Giwa.

These Rerun elections ordered by the Court of Appeal Abuja Division, involve the APC and its candidates, Rt. Hon. Ibrahim Baba Hassan for the House of Representatives seat, PRP and its candidate Hon. Mohammed Adamu Alkali and other political parties, while for the Senatorial District seat, it involves Amb. Chris Giwa and his party the APC, and Gyang Zi (Esq) and his party the Labour Party (LP) among other political parties.

The Court had directed INEC to conduct these elections within the next 90 days, but matters have already started taking center stage as pundits continue to consider the effect(s) of the Judgments so delivered visa-vies the political situation in the state.

Pundits, who spoke to REALITY are strongly of the firm believe that the political situation in relation to the planned rerun would generate voters’ apathy and it would generate huge protest votes in the state. But however submitted that “whichever way the political situation goes, it would be favorable to the APC, as its members, elected political officers, and supporters would simply focus on winning. An apathy to the process would only reduce the votes of other participating parties”.

They further submitted that the internal conflict and crisis rocking the Plateau State chapter of the PDP would also be a blessing to APC and its candidates since those who have pledged to assist the APC from day one of the elections would continue to do so.

Adding that, “those who would want to waste their votes can simply do so by casting their votes for the PDP the second time”.

MORE ON THIS AND LEGAL ANALYSIS COMING…

Sunday 29 October 2023

PLATEAU: DON’T TAKE UNAUTHORIZED RESPONSIBILITIES FROM IMPOSTERS. CHAIRMAN JOS NORTH LGC, HON. USMAN BALA, BREAKS SILENCE, WARNS

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

Allegedly suspended Chairman of Jos North Local Government Council of Plateau State, Hon. Usman Bala has warned the staff of the Local Government Council (LGC) never to take unauthorized responsibilities from imposters now in the Council.

He also warned the Management Staff of the Council not to sign illegal cheques issued or brought to their notice by these imposters in the Council.

The Chairman of the Council, who is among the 17 Local Government Council Chairmen and Councilors in Plateau state who are currently challenging their suspension from office by the state Governor, Caleb Mutfwang (Esq), also extended this warning to, Directors, Accountants, Unit Heads, Cashiers, among other.

Chairman Usman, who currently had to break his silence over the issues happening in and around Jos North LGC in a Press Statement signed by Abdullahi Okechukwu, the Supervisory Councilor, Special Duties, in Jos North LGA, dated 28th – 10 -2023, stated in part that, “He said the Council under his leadership is not aware of any Standing Committee on Revenue Mobilization and therefore warned those parading themselves to desist forthwith, as the Council will not tolerate those, who go outside his directives to connive with the imposters to commit all manner of financial impropriety”.

Hon. Usman who used the Press Statement to remind the staff of the LGC of the existing Court Order barring Governor Caleb Mutfwang from appointing Caretaker Committee Chairmen for the 17 Local Government Councils, while appealing to the  Directors in the Council not to indulge in any unlawful act of signing cheques forthwith, reiterated that, “His commitment to ensuring the equitable allocation of funds as the duly elected Chairman of the Council backed by Law of the Federal Republic of Nigeria will ensure that the people benefit from the much needed dividends of democracy”.

READ THE FULL TEXT BELOW:-

HON. USMAN BALA JOS NORTH CHAIRMAN OF PLATEAU STATE

JOS NORTH COUNCIL BOSS WARNS STAFF AGAINST TAKING UNAUTHORIZED RESPONSIBILITIES FROM IMPOSTORS.

-ADVISES THOSE PARADING THEMSELVES AS MEMBERS OF THE COMMITTEE ON REVENUE MOBILIZATION OF DIRE CONSEQUENCES.

The Executive Chairman of Jos North Local Government Council, Hon. Shehu Bala Usman has warned staff of the Council against taking unauthorized responsibilities from impostors masquerading as sole administrator thereby siphoning public funds.

The Chairman, who expressed serious concerns over the activities of some of these staff specifically, drew the attention of Directors, Accountants, Unit Heads, and Cashiers, warning them that punitive measures await any of them involved in the unauthorized withdrawal of the Council’s fund with individuals, who bypass established processes.

He said the Council under his leadership is not aware of any Standing Committee on Revenue Mobilization and therefore warned those parading themselves to desist forthwith as the Council will not tolerate those, who go outside his directives to connive with the imposters to commit all manner of financial impropriety.

Usman reiterated his commitment to ensuring the equitable allocation of funds as the duly elected Chairman of the Council backed by Law of the Federal Republic of Nigeria to ensure that the people benefit from the much needed dividends of democracy.

He reminded the staff about the existing Court Order barring Governor Caleb Mutfwang from appointing Caretaker Committee Chairmen for the 17 Local Government Councils, while appealing to Directors not to indulge in any unlawful act of signing cheques forthwith.

The Chairman warned officials of the Nigeria Union of Local Government Employees (NULGE), Jos North Branch against adhering to the indefinite strike and advised them against taking unauthorized responsibilities, noting that, Government will not tolerate staff who collaborate with any persons whose existence is not backed by Law to misuse public funds.

He observed that such actions is capable of hampering the execution of ongoing projects in the locality which have direct impact on the lives of the people.

He pledged to have an interface with the staff soon noting that Council would do everything it can to better their welfare.

Usman called on the peace and hospitable people of Jos North, not to be deterred, as he assured that all those with bad intentions to take advantage of the people will not succeed.

E-sign:

Abdullahi Okechukwu,

Supervisory Councillor,

Special Duties,

Jos North LGA.

28th – 10 – 2023.

Saturday 28 October 2023

PLATEAU STATE PDP CANDIDATES STOOD ELECTION AS INDEPENDENT CANDIDATES. COURT OF APPEAL RE-ECHOS PWAJOK (SAN) POSITION

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

Court of Appeal Abuja Division has reechoed the position of Learned Silk, Edward Pwajok (SAN) that, the Plateau State chapter of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) candidates in the 2023 general elections stood in the contests as Independent Candidates.

The Court held this position yesterday Friday, while delivering Judgment in the Appeal filed by Rt. Hon. Ibrahim Baba Hassan, seeking the disqualification of Hon. Muhammad Adam Alkali, over alleged certificate forgery.

EDWARD PWAJOK (SAN) COUNSEL TO APC

You would also recall that Pwajok (SAN) had advised the electorate in Plateau State on the eve of the elections not to waste their votes, “As a vote for PDP is a wasted vote”.

In its Judgment, the Court of Appeal declined to take a decision on the alleged certificate forgery allegation on Hon. Alikali on the ground that, the trial Tribunal also did not take a decision on it.

The Court according to our source in a unanimous judgment held that, “Having found that the Lower Tribunal, had not decided on the alleged certificate forgery, the Appeal Court cannot give any judgment to that effect”.

The Appellate Arm of the Tribunal, led by Hon. Justice, Okon Efreti Abang, adding that, “You don’t appeal on sentimental grounds, but against the Judgment of the Tribunal. Where there is no decision, there cannot be an Appeal,” justice Abang held.

You would recall that, Rt. Hon. Ibrahim Baba Hassan and his party, the All Progressives Congress (APC), had challenged the educational qualification of Hon. Muhammad Adam Alkali, of the People’s Redemption Party (PRP), alleging that he had forged his Primary School Certificate to contest the 2023 election into Bassa/Jos North Federal Constituency of Plateau State.

On the issue of the Appellant’s Relief wanting the Court to disqualify the PDP’s candidate, over noncompliance with the provisions of the Constitution of the Federal Republic of Nigeria 1999 (as amended), Justice Abang, held that, the PDP candidate stood election as an independent candidate which is unlawful.

“The 2nd Respondent (Hon. Musa Agah), having not validly sponsored, contested the election as an Independent Candidate, which is alien to the constitution”. The Court held.

The Court has ordered the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC), to conduct rerun election within 90 days, just as it did in one of the sister Appeals that disqualified and nullified the election of Hon. Musa Agah, of the People’s PDP.

Justice Abang held that, “To avoid this court given contradictory decision, the Independent National Electoral Commission (INEC) is ordered to conduct rerun election within 90 days.”

In another development also on Friday, the Court of Appeal Abuja Division on the Appeal concerning Mikang/Shendam/Quanpan Federal Constituency of Plateau State has ordered INEC to withdraw the Certificate of Return issued to Hon. Isaac Kwallu of the PDP and re-issue it to Hon. John Dafaan of the APC.

Thursday 26 October 2023

PLATEAU: POLITICAL ACCUSATION AGAINST COURT OF APPEAL PRESIDENT, IGP, 17 LGC CHAIRMEN, OTHERS IN 5 MONTHS. AN OVERVIEW

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

Within the last 5 months and after the swearing-in ceremony on 29th May 2023, of the New Administration in Plateau State, the level of political accusations in the state’s political space has expanded from the 17 Local Government Council Administrations in the state to the Federal level.

The security operatives in the state have not been spared as the Commissioner of Police (CP) in the state and the Inspector General of Police (IGP) have also gotten their own share of accusations.

Earlier, the immediate past administration in the state had been attacked for a lot of failures and poor administration, which included the plunging of the state into huge debts and employing the state indigenes with a lack of due process, thereby inflating the wage bill for the incoming state government now led by Governor Caleb Mutfwang (Esq).

The 17 Local Government Council Chairmen inherited by the Administration of Governor Caleb (Esq) are already on alleged suspension for one or two accusations too.

Concerning the security operatives, they have been accused of taking sides in the political war and legal tussle between the State Administration and the suspended LGC Chairmen, despite a suit to which they are parties still pending in court.

The IGP through the State Commissioner of Police was dragged to an Area Court and the Federal High Court in Abuja, during the vacation period on the issue above.

Concerning the National/State Houses of Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal, the Panel Chaired by Hon. Justice B. M. Tukur was dragged before the National Judicial Council (NJC), over alleged perceived bias and interest of the Panelists in all the Petitions filed by Petitioners against the ruling Peoples Democratic Party (PDP). While on their own party, the Petitioners, the All Progressives Congress (APC) and the Labour Party (LP), have equally accused the Hon Justice William-led Panel and the Governorship Election Petitions Tribunal that sat in the state of miscarriage of Justice because of similar perceived interest of the Panelists.

However, when the people of Plateau State thought that all the issues had been exhausted, a Coalition of over 15 Civil Society groups on Tuesday, threatened to shut down Courtrooms, if the EFCC failed to heed the call to Investigate the President of the Court of Appeal over the abused of her office.

The Coalition under the aegis of the Forum of Coalition of Anti-Corruption Organizations in Nigeria, issued the threat while briefing the media in Jos, on Tuesday.

Chairman of the Forum, Mr. Wole Adewale, said the forum has obtained all conversations with Hon, Justice Monica Donbam, where she agreed to the demands of some former Governors including several appointed federal officers.

In a swift reaction to this accusation, the Patriotic APC Media Front in a rejoinder, dated 25-10-2023, has called on security operatives, especially, the DSS to launch a manhunt for the author(s).

The Patriotic APC Media Front in their press statement in part stated: “However, since the author boasts of having evidence, including recorded conversations, the security agencies especially, the Department of State Services are called upon to launch a manhunt on the author(s) and trail the purveyors of these series of character assassination on the person of the President of the Court of Appeal and bring them to book, so it would serve as deterrents to intending culprits”.

TO BE CONTINUED..

Wednesday 25 October 2023

EDITORIAL: THE BEST TIME/WAY FOR GOV. CALEB MUTFWANG TO MAKE PEACE IN PLATEAU STATE IS NOW

There is always no time to complete competing demands or activities in life hence, the need for choice and planning and setting priorities right, either as individuals, groups, or organizations.

The “Time” factor and the scarcity of resources have always called for group reasoning from the family, group, and organizational settings.

It is this necessity that makes families, departments, and governments, to effectively employ the use of experts in resolving issues timely and with limited or low cost.

GOV. MUTFWANG OF PLATEAU STATE

The State of Peace they say is very expensive to manage, but still cheaper than crisis or conflict situations.

In Plateau state, and within the incumbent administration of Governor Caleb Mutfwang, lots of issues have risen that call for debates, condemnation, or commendation.

However, with the twist and developments at the Court of Appeal as it relates to recent judgments, which are against the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), and its candidates in the National Assembly elections of 25th February, 2023, the need for a reconciliation and reversal of alleged condemnable acts by Governor Caleb’s administration may enjoy this available chance and the TIME IS NOW!

FACTS are that, with the recent Judgment of the Court of Appeal sacking Sen. Simon Mwadkwon from the Red Chambers of the National Assembly, the Governor must start looking beyond his current recruited staff and Advisers and begin to project his survival and that of his mandate for a soft political landing.

It is also a fact that, Plateau State has 8 members of the House of Representatives. At the moment, Plateau State PDP has 5, APC has 3. But the election of all the 5 members of the PDP are been challenged by the APC in the Court of Appeal on the same basis that the PDP has no structure in Plateau State and had therefore not conducted primaries that produced any candidate.

And, the Court of Appeal has said that much when it invalidated the election of Sen. Mwadkwon for “non-compliance with a Subsisting Court Order from the Plateau State High Court made in 2020 that 12 LGAs must participate in the PDP congress before a candidate will be nominated for an election”.

The 5 APC members in the House may have to, like Sen. Mwadkwon, also go.

This is a time and an opportunity to strategize for peace-building and settlement in all conflicts generated by these levels of actors, if any.

On the side of the State House of Assembly, the House has 24 members. As of today, PDP has 15 members, 8 are APC, while YPP has 1.

However, the election of all the 15 members of the PDP are being challenged in the Court of Appeal on the same basis that the PDP has no structure in Plateau state to which, the Appeal Court has agreed to in the case of Sen. Mwadkwon.

Since the Court of Appeal is bound by their earlier decision in Sen. Mwadkwon case delivered just last week Sunday, this set of House of Assembly members may also go.

The need to make peace at this level is very necessary as the alleged suspension of Local Council Chairmen which started at this level may be reversed with no glory attached to the name of the Governor.

The Time to take the right steps is also now.

Tuesday 24 October 2023

AMB. G. Y. GOTOM, ADVISES SENATE PRESIDENT TO STAY OFF PLATEAU CENTRAL SENATORIAL DISTRICT ELECTION PETITION

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

Amb. G. Y. Gotom, the candidate of the People’s Democratic Party (PDP) in the Plateau Central Senatorial District election, conducted by INEC on the 25th of February, 2020 has called on the President of the Nigerian Senate, Sen. G. Akpabio, to stay off the decision of the National/State Houses of Assembly Election Petition Tribunal sitting in Jos, Plateau State, as Counsels in the matter adopt their final written addresses today.

You would recall that, the PDP and Amb. Gotom are challenging the victory of Sen. Diket Plang and the All Progressives Congress (APC), over the Plateau Central Senatorial District election through the Petition they filed at the Tribunal.

Amb. Gotom, who spoke to his supporters, immediately after the adoption of the written addresses, which was conducted via Zoom and before the Tribunal Panel Chaired by Hon. Justice Tukur, also advised that, “anybody, who must be a governor in Plateau State must not be a tribalist or just show love to the Ngas Natation, but must love all citizens of Plateau State alike”.

Gotom said, “Democracy is the Government for the People and it must be seen to be by the people and for the People”.

Adding that, “It is for these reasons that the Senate President should not interfere with the interest of the electorates in the Central Senatorial District of Plateau State, who have voted the PDP and himself as the Senator to represent them”.

The highlight of the brief discussion with his supporters, saw all attendees praying and giving good testimonies of how humanly good Amb. Gotom is.

Earlier, Counsel to the Petitioners, Chief Prof. Mike Ozekhome had given the supporters high hopes that the Petition would succeed, as the APC were mere interlopers in the affairs of the PDP and its issue of structure.

According to Ozekhome, “These issues have been settled by the Supreme Court of Nigeria”.

The Tribunal has adjourned the Petition for Judgment to a date that would be communicated to Counsels in the matter.

TO BE CONTINUED…

Friday 20 October 2023

PLATEAU: THE TRIBUNAL ERRED WHEN IT SAID NO EVIDENCE IS BEFORE IT TO SHOW NONCOMPLIANCE—DR. NENTAWE, APC STATED IN NOTICE OF APPEAL

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

The governorship candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC) in the 25th February, 2023, Governorship election in Plateau State, Dr. Nentawe Yilwatda has stated in his Appeal before the Court Appeal, wherein he is challenging the Judgment delivered by the Governorship Election Petition Tribunal Panel that, there was a grave miscarriage of justice by the Tribunal and that the Tribunal erred when it said there was no evidence before it to show that there was noncompliance to the Electoral Act in the conduct of the Governorship Election in the state.

In their Notice of Appeal filed by their Counsel, Professor Kayode Olatoke (SAN), Nentawe disagrees with the decision of the Tribunal in saying that, there was no evidence before it to show that the governorship election was not conducted in substantial compliance with the Electoral Act.

Nentawe and the APC stated that they have demonstrated that, there was over-voting as shown in form EC8As as presented and identified by their respective witnesses.

Adding that “Duplicated results of voter registers and extracts from BVAS machine devices were tendered before the Tribunal”, while maintaining also that there is overwhelming evidence that the Governorship election was not conducted in substantial compliance with the Electoral Act.

Nentawe further submitted that “An election where there was no proper accreditation, where there is over voting, non-collation of results and non-usage of voter registers, as well as, when the person declared as the winner was not qualified to contest, cannot be said to be an election conducted in substantial compliance with the Electoral Act 2022”.

Nentawe further submitted that “the judgment of the trial Tribunal was against the weight of evidence” and therefore, prayed the Court of Appeal to allow his Appeal by setting aside the entire judgment of the trial Tribunal.

TO BE CONTINUED….

 

“THERE WAS A GRAVE MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE. WE ARE CHALLENGING THE QUALIFICATION OF PDP AND GOV. MUTFWANG AND NOT THEIR CONGRESS”. APC, DR. NENTAWE, STATE ON APPEAL

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

Not being satisfied with the Judgment of the Governorship Election Petition Tribunal Panel that sat in Jos, Plateau State, the All Progressives Congress (APC) and its governorship candidate, Dr Nentawe Yilwtda in the 18th March, 20203 election have approached the Court of Appeal, Abuja Division, stating that there was a grave miscarriage of Justice in the Judgment delivered by the Panel.

Nentawe disclosed in his Appeal that he is not challenging the procedures for the purported PDP congress, but the non-qualification of Mutfwang to contest the election having not been duly sponsored.

He argued that, having been duly established in accordance with the extant orders of the Plateau State High Court through documentary evidence and oral testimonies of his witnesses, his petition is hinged on the validity or otherwise of the repeated congress of the 25th September 2021.

The appellant further argued that the Judgments of the Court of Appeal in respect of PDP’s congresses have not been altered, and as such, the decisions ought to be binding on the Tribunal in arriving at its conclusion.

In the Notice of Appeal filed by his Counsel, Professor Kayode Olatoke (SAN), Nentawe claims that the Tribunal in striking out his witnesses’ statements on oath and documents presented, were in clear breach of his right to fair hearing and fair trial.

According to Nentawe in a press statement signed by Shittu Bamaiyi, the candidate in his Appeal stated that “It was wrong to hold that Emmanuel Go’ar and Emmanuel Macham are not witnesses of the Tribunal but his own”.

Adding that, “The Tribunal came to a wrong conclusion in that decision because “The two mentioned persons were subpoenaed witnesses.

Explain that, “The two witnesses could not have gone to the court to give evidence, without being compelled by the order of the Tribunal to do so, while further pointing out that the two persons are not members of his political party, but that of PDP.

According to him, the fact that the two witnesses were issued with subpoena to attend the Tribunal upon his request, it did not vitiate the fact that they were witnesses of the Tribunal.

Nentawe maintained that Messrs Go’ar and Macham were subpoenaed as adversaries, whose witness depositions cannot accompany his petition as wrongly held by the Tribunal.

He argued that subpoenaed witnesses are regulated by the provisions of the Electoral Act, and the Federal High Court Civil Procedure Rules, 2019.

He further submitted that the period of 21 days within which an election petition must be filed does not apply to the two subpoenaed witnesses.

The Appellant stated that the Tribunal misconceived his unique case, in challenging the sponsorship of Caleb Mutfwang to contest the governorship election.

TO BE CONTINUED…

Wednesday 18 October 2023

PLATEAU: BREAKING: FINALLY, SUSPENDED LGC CHAIRMEN SUIT IS FIXED FOR 9TH AND 29TH NOV. 2023 FOR HEARING, AS INTENDING JOINDER WITHDRAWS

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

The coast is now clear for the hearing of the substantive suit No: PLD/J357/2023, filed by allegedly suspended Local Government Council (LGC) Chairmen in Plateau State, over their suspension from office by the Plateau State Governor, Caleb Mutfwang.

Another Defendant to the suit is the State Attorney General (A-G).

You would recall that, REALITY had earlier reported that, the suit was finally reassigned to a 3rd Judge, Hon. Justice Samchi, by the Plateau State Chief Judge.

After all deliberations at the hearing today, the Court has adjourned the suit for two purposes. First, to hear the Motion for the leave of Court for extension of time to file the Defendants’ Response to the Originating Summons out of time and to hear the substantive matter.

While the Court adjourned the hearing of the Motion to the 9th of November, 2023, it also adjourned the hearing of the substantive suit to the 29th November, 20203.

Earlier, the Court had struck out the application for joinder filed by, Hon. Zulfa Bitrus Rimven (the former Chairman of Langtang North), after it was withdrawn by his Counsel, Hassan (Esq).

The Court also refused to grant cost for the withdrawal as requested by the Defendants’ Counsel on the ground that, their response to the suit was even filed 27 days out of the time allowed by the Rules of Court and also that, there was no prayers for a deeming order.

According to the Court, “the event was not completed to attract cost”.

You would also recall that, REALITY had reported that, because of the absence of the Defendants’ Counsel in Court at the last sitting, the Court kept on hold the applications made by the Counsel to the Claimants, Tob, Kekemeke (Esq) for a date to be taken to move all the Motions in the matter alongside the Origination Summons and the application to withdraw the application for Joinder filed by Hon. Zulfa Bitrus Rimven (the former Chairman of Langtang North) by his Counsel.

As at the hearing today, the suspended LGC Chairmen were in attendance with the Leaders of their respective Legislative Councils, accept for two Chairmen who were represented by their Deputies.

Thursday 12 October 2023

PLATEAU: BREAKING: FINALLY, SUSPENDED LGC CHAIRMEN SUIT AGAINST GOV. MUTFWANG AND THE STATE ATTORNEY GENERAL (A-G) HAS BEEN REASSIGNED TO A 3RD JUDGE

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

The suit No: PLD/J357/2023, filed by allegedly suspended Local Government Council (LGC) Chairmen in Plateau State has finally been reassigned to a 3rd Judge, Hon. Justice Samchi, by the Plateau State Chief Judge.

You would recall that, suit No: PLD/J357/2023 filed in May, 2023, by way of Originating Summons has been handled by Hon. Justice Kunda, and Hon. Justice S. Bakfur.

While Hon. Justice Kunda adjourned the Matter to the 25th of September, 2023 for hearing of all the Applications therein, Hon. Justice Bakfur, adjourned it to the 28th of September, 2023, and being the Vacation Judge, REALITY gathered that he returned the file back on the 13th of September, 2023, to the Plateau State Chief Judge.

Although the matter was slated for mention in the Plateau State High Court presided over by Hon. Justice Samchi today, the proceedings was stalled, owing to, the absence of the Counsel to the Defendants (Gov. Caleb Mutfwang (Esq) and the State Attorney) in Court.

Because of the absence of the Defendants, the Court kept on hold the applications made by the Counsel to the Claimants, Tob, Kekemeke (Esq) for a date to be taken to move all the Motions in the matter with the Origination Summons and the application to withdraw the application for Joinder filed by Hon. Zulfa Bitrus Rimven (the former Chairman of Langtang North) by his Counsel.

The matter has further been adjourned by the Court to the 18th of October, 2023, for mention again.

While reacting to the development and fielding answers to questions from Journalists at the Court premises, the Counsel to the Claimants expressed surprise on why he being the Counsel of the Claimants and the Counsel to Hon. Zulfa were served hearing Notices and the Counsel to Defendants were not served.

He also expressed hope that the matter would be handled now that the 3rd Judge has been assigned while reviewing the journey the file has passed through in the past few months.

Wednesday 11 October 2023

25TH FEBRUARY POLL: PDP, HON. MUSA AGAH, MUHAMMAD ADAMU, DANIEL ASAMA WERE NOT QUALIFIED—RT. HON. BABA HASSAN TELLS COURT OF APPEAL

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

The candidate of the All Progressives Congress (APC) for Bassa/Jos-North Federal Constituency of Plateau State, Rt. Hon. Ibrahim Baba Hassan has reiterated that Hon. Musa Agah of the PDP, Muhammad Adamu Alkali of the PRP, and Daniel Asama Ago of the Labour Party (LP), were not qualified to have contested the election conducted by INEC on the 25th of February, 2023 in the first place.

Rt. Hon. Ibrahim Baba Hassan stated this among the 5 grounds in the Notice of Appeal he filed before the Court of Appeal through his Counsel, Magaji SAN.

Rt. Hon. Hassan who is complaining against the entire Judgment of the petition he filed at the Lower Tribunal and the rulings therein stated that the Tribunal erred as there was a “miscarriage of justice”.

Baba Hassan, specifically stated that it was wrong for the trial tribunal to have refused to determine his Preliminary Objection on jurisdiction, in accordance with  Section 53(2) of the first Schedule of the Electoral Act, while contended that Musa Agah of the PDP and Adamu Alkali of the PRP, were not qualified to contest the election.

The appellant pointed out that the Court of Appeal in Jos, had nullified the election of Hon. Musa Agah on the ground that he was not qualified to contest the by-election of February 26, 2022, because his party, the PDP had no structure to sponsor him.

Rt. Hon. Baba Hassan (The Appellant) maintained that it is settled law that the Court of Appeal which is the Apex Court in National Assembly election matters, had already determined the status of Agah and that of his party in participating in the February 25th,2023, National Assembly Election.

Baba Hassan argued that Muhammad Adamu Alkali of the PRP, having submitted a forged Primary School Certificate to INEC, as testified by some of his witnesses, was not also qualified to contest the election.

According to him, it is on record that one of Alkali ‘s witnesses by name Tijani, had denied the content of the Primary School Certificate submitted by the PRP candidate.

He pointed out that, his petition is anchored on a new regime of the electoral Act, which conveys a novel provision that clearly states that two or more candidates may be made respondents to the same petition and their case may for the sake of convenience be heard at the same time, but for all purposes (including the taking of security) the election petition, shall be deemed to be as separate petition against each of the respondents.

Baba Hassan described his case as triple decker petition, against Agah, Alkali and Ago.

Adding that, “The findings of the trial tribunal were based on the old regime of the Electoral Act”.

He therefore prayed the Court to grant him all the reliefs sought in his petition, and also declare him the first runner-up with the highest lawful votes during the February National Assembly Election for the Bassa/Jos North Federal Constituency.

You would recall that REALITY had reported that the political climate is beclouded by fear and anxiety as the news filtering into the state indicates that the Court of Appeal, Abuja Division, may have scheduled 13th October 2023, to commence hearing of some of the Election Petition Appeals before it.

You would also recall that, the Tribunal Panels that sat in Jos the Plateau State capital commenced their Judgments with Petitions concerning the National Assembly elections conducted on the 25th of February, 2023 by INEC, before the State House of Assembly Election Petitions for the simple fact that the National Assembly elections came earlier.

From investigation, REALITY had also reported that, most political gladiators in Plateau State have shifted their base to Abuja with lots of nocturnal meetings going on in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) in relation to the upcoming Court of Appeal sitting.

REALITY also gathered that the Court of Appeal may have set 5 cases arising from the Judgments delivered by the Lower Tribunals for their adoption of Counsel Written Addresses.

They include, but are not limited to the following below:

1) Appeal of Gyan Zi Vs Mwatkom.

2). Appeal of Cris Giwa Vs Mwatkom

3) Appeal of Muhd Alkali Vs Musa Agah

4) Appeal of Baba Hassan Vs Agah, Alkali & others.

5) Appeal of John Dafan Vs Alex Kwalu.

TO BE CONTINUED…

PLATEAU: AWARD OF LANGTANG -WASE -BASHAR ROAD: WASE EQUITY PROJECT COMMENDS, RT. HON. AHMED WASE, PRESIDENT BOLA TINUBU

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

The Wase Equity Project has expressed delight to learn that the contract for the construction of the Langtang-Wase-Bashar road in Plateau State by the Federal Government of Nigeria has been given the needed attention.

In a press statement dated 11/10/23, signed by Hon. Abubakar Muhammad Badu (Dan Malikin Wase), the Publicity Secretary of Wase Equity Project, made available to media houses including REALITY in Jos, Plateau State, the Wase Equity Project stated that “This is a significant development that will open up the area in terms of transportation and development”.

Adding that, “We would also like to commend the renewed hope, APC administration, led by His Excellency Bola Ahmed Tinubu, for ensuring that this project becomes a reality. This road construction project is a vital step towards the transformation and development of the Wase Federal Constituency”.

READ THE FULL STATEMENT BELOW:-

PRESS STATEMENT

WASE EQUITY PROJECT COMMENDS THE RENEWED HOPE ADMINISTRATION LED BY PRESIDENT BOLA AHMED TINUBU FOR THE AWARD OF LANGTANG -WASE -BASHAR ROAD

11/10/23

The Wase Equity Project is delighted to learn about the recent award of the contract for the construction of Langtang-Wase-Bashar road in Plateau State by the federal government of Nigeria. This is a significant development that will open up the area in terms of transportation and development.

We would like to emphasize the continuous determination of the member representing Wase federal constituency, RT Hon Ahmed Idris Wase CON, to see the progress and growth of the area. His hard work and dedication have resulted in this significant achievement, and we appreciate his efforts and leadership.

We would also like to commend the renewed hope,APC administration, led by His Excellency Bola Ahmed Tinubu, for ensuring that this project becomes a reality. This road construction project is a vital step towards the transformation and development of the Wase federal constituency.

We wish President Tinubu and Hon Ahmed Maje good health, strength, and protection against any calamity in the discharge of their duties. We are optimistic that more significant developments are coming to Wase federal constituency, and we look forward to witnessing the growth and progress of the area under the leadership of RT Hon Ahmed Idris Wase CON.

Abubakar Muhammad Badu

(Dan Malikin Wase)

Publicity Secretary

PLATEAU: BREAKING: LITIGANTS HAVE STARTED PETITIONING THE NJC OVER THE NON-ASSIGNMENT OR NON-REASSIGNMENT OF THEIR CASES IN PLATEAU STATE HIGH COURT

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

Many litigants in Plateau State have started petitioning the National Judicial Council (NJC) over the non-assignment or non-reassignment of their cases after the vacation period in the State. REALITY just gathered.

According to some of these aggrieved litigants, who explained their reason(s) for petitioning the NJC concerning the development to REALITY, they seem not to know the faith of their case anymore as the dates their cases were adjourned, have come and gone and the vacation period has ended.

Others seem not to know which Court is to handle their cases anymore, as two judges have handled their cases and adjourned same to dates that have also lapsed after the vacation period.

DETAILS OF THE PETITIONS COMING SOON…  

Tuesday 10 October 2023

PLATEAU: FEARS AND ANXIETY, AS THE COURT OF APPEAL IS SET TO COMMENCE HEARING ELECTION PETITION APPEALS FROM 13TH OCTOBER

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

The political climate is currently beclouded by fear and anxiety as the news filtering into Plateau State indicates that the Court of Appeal, Abuja Division, may have scheduled 13th October 2023, to commence hearing of some of the Election Petition Appeals before it.

You would recall that, the Tribunal Panels that sat in Jos the Plateau State capital commenced their Judgments with Petitions concerning the National Assembly elections conducted on the 25th of February, 2023 by INEC, before the State House of Assembly Election Petitions for the simple fact that the National Assembly elections came earlier.

From investigation, REALITY gathered that, most political gladiators in Plateau State have shifted their base to Abuja with lots of nocturnal meetings going on in the Federal Capital Territory (FCT) in relation to the upcoming Court of Appeal sitting.

REALITY also gathered that the Court of Appeal may have set 5 cases arising from the Judgments delivered by the Lower Tribunals for their adoption of Counsel Written Addresses.

They include, but are not limited to the following below:

1) Appeal of Gyan Zi Vs Mwatkom.

2). Appeal of Cris Giwa Vs Mwatkom

3) Appeal of Muhd Alkali Vs Musa Agah

4) Appeal of Baba Hassan Vs Agah, Alkali & others.

5) Appeal of John Dafan Vs Alex Kwalu.

TO BE CONTINUED…

Monday 9 October 2023

PLATEAU: TRIBUNAL JUDGMENTS: APPEALS AT THE COURT OF APPEAL TO COMMENCE SOON--INVESTIGATION

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

There is a high preparation on ground for the hearing of Appeals filed by Litigants (Political Parties and their Candidates), challenging the outcome of judgments delivered by Tribunal Panels that sat in Plateau State by the Court of Appeal, Jos Division, in few weeks. REALITY can authoritatively state.

You would recall that, there were judgments delivered by the Governorship and the National/State Houses of Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal Panels that sat in Plateau State in the last one month and not being satisfied with the outcome, REALITY gathered that, most parties have appealed against the Judgments to the Court of Appeal.

It is of noted that, out of the 60 days provided by Law for the determination of the Appeals at the Court of Appeal from the Tribunals, the Notice of Appeal is expected to be filed within 7 days after the delivery of the Judgment and within 10 days to transmit Records and within  another 7 days to file Briefs.

The Responses to the Briefs may take another 7 days and would be replied to within 5 days, before the Appeals are ripe for hearing by the Appellate Arm of the Tribunal.

MORE TO COME ON THE APPEALS SO FAR FILLED IN PLATEAU STATE.

Friday 6 October 2023

RELOCATION OF IMT ENUGU TO OWO, THE STORM KEEPS GATHERING. POSSIBLE WAYS OUT

By: Nnabugwu Chizoba,

The amalgamation of the then College of Technology and the Institute of Administraton way back in 1973 gave birth to what is today known as the Institute of Management and Technology (IMT) Enugu.

The 50 years IMT apart from her reputation as a legacy project is the pride of the old Eastern Region of Nigeria. In the present political structuring of Nigeria, the former region has spread into the South East and South South Zones of the Country, comprising almost all the 11 states, but one, namely: Enugu, Anambra, Ebonyi, Imo and Abia, in the South East and Cross River, Rivers, Akwa Ibom, Bayalsa, and part of Delta State in the South South. (Note, the states are arranged in no particular order). It is also not out of place to deposit as a matter of fact that, the IMT, a cherished product of very high value is a pride of the Nigerian Nation.

The brief preamble above is intended to draw the attention of the public, arouse the interest and commitment of the genuine reader of this piece, the young and the old, as well as, challenge critical stakeholders of the IMT Enugu, like the State Assembly, the Alumni Association, the Student Union Government (SUG) and the Ogui, Nike and Ugwuaji communities, to take special interest about what IMT is and all other structures and institutions in the South East that are either 50 years or slightly above it.

Lovers of Enugu state, especially followers of the round leather game, football, would in a jiffy recall an incident about the Rangers International Football Club of Enugu (the pride of the East) concerning an attempt to sale it to a buyer, who was not interested in retaining the name of the club, after the purchase agreement are concluded. Well-meaning citizens of the South East, who were agitated by the absurdity of erasing the name “Rangers” appealed for retention of the name for obvious reasons and if this appeal was not to be respected that, the idea of selling the club should be jettisoned. In the end, common sense prevailed and the sale of “Rangers” was abandoned.

Another incident was the attempt to merge IMT and the Enugu State University of Science and Technology (ESUT). This too, did not go down well with custodians of the real values of the people. The resistance that attended the proposed merger led the leaders of that time to drop the idea, after pushing it to a point that violent reactions almost erupted. This resistance, from record, was hinged on historical facts and values.

Meaningful deductions can be drawn from the two identified cases that happened during military rule in Nigeria. Presently, Nigeria is practicing democratic governance, which is interpreted to be, a government of the people, by the people and for the people. In a Constitutional Democracy, which Nigeria is practicing, the Constitution is the grand norm.

The Constitution of Nigeria is very clear in its provision that, “Protection” and “Welfare” of the citizens are the core responsibilities of government. Presently, both “Protection” and “Welfare” elude the citizens of Enugu State and Nigeria at large. It is on record that, the Enugu State Governor and other Governors of the South Eastern states are not only battling insecurity, but are confronted with a challenge of “Legitimacy” considering that, Non-state Actors share authority with them. These actors issue orders at will and the citizens obey massively, but unwillingly. This development is strange to governance. The Governors oppose and resist vehemently the non-state actors because, they (the Governors) know the implications of the activities of the non-state actors. The governors are not comfortable with the operations of the non-state actors and will never support such. The Governors are not only finding the situation unpalatable, but very difficult to curb or supress. The established fact is, the ugly situations arose in the first place due to misrule and poor governance.

The “Sit at Home Order”, which has economic and social effects is a huge source of concern and worry to both the citizens and the government and should be the pre-occupation of those close to the government, rather than disturbing the authorities with primordial, selfish and parochial issues, with no real values. Such issues at best serve as distraction to the authorities and source of pain, injury and disaffection in the land, creating acrimony and divisions between the government and her subjects.

One instrument of division being dangled presently in the face of the government by the enemies of the state and the people is the alleged plan of the relocation of IMT Enugu to Owo. The rumour about it is gaining grounds. Call it “traction”, if you like.

Some of the questions people are already asking with regard to the alleged plan of relocating IMT Enugu to Owo are the following and not limited to them:

Is there any truth in the rumour?

Why are those in authorities not speaking out to clear the issue?

What will it cause to dispel the rumour immediately, if no such plan is on-going?

Why would anybody with his or her senses intact come out with such a plan?

Why is the plan a nocturnal issue and conducted in a clandestine manner?

Pundits in the Educational Sector/Industry have also raised their own sets of questions, which include and not limited to the following:-

What will happen to the current IMT space, if not possible land grabbing?

What will happen to the infrastructure recently completed by both the federal and state governments?

Why destroy to rebuild?

The pundits have opined that, many youths are still not admitted and why can’t the state Government build another higher institution in Owo, if it desires and name it anything, but leave the IMT Enugu alone?

In the list of numerous challenges faced by the citizens of Enugu State, the least now and in many years to come is and would still be, the relocation of IMT Enugu.

The pundits as a matter of fact are already calling on the Enugu State Government to collaborate with stakeholders of the project IMT to identify and market the Tourist Values of the present location and seek more ways of exploring and realizing extensively the huge benefits of IMT in her present location.

The planned IMT@50 Celebration therefore provides an opportunity for the government to show massive support towards showcasing the rich values of IMT and her location to the globe. The State Government has been urged to embrace this challenge.

Pundits have further reminded the Government of Enugu State that, her citizens are not only suffering, but dying in their numbers from preventable and curable diseases, poverty and hunger. They drew the attention of the government to the fact that, communities are divided along sentimental lines, while noting equally that, opportunities for gainful employment in both the public and private sectors are constantly shrinking with no hope of averting them. Continuing, they maintained that, insecurity, kidnapping, armed robbery and other forms of crime are on the rise and that the intelligent, creative and able body young people in Enugu State are roaming the street. According to them “Many young people have become raw materials of the agents of destabilization. Some have turned into tools in the hands of conflict merchants, while some have become the leaders of very horrible groups”. Adding that, “the list of those classified as infant terrible is also on the increase”.

The views of some discussants towards resolving the identified challenges above are to the effect that, the focus of the government should be to provide citizens of Enugu state with better livelihood options.

The pursuit of public oriented policies with direct economic impact on citizens was recommended by the pundits who also noted that effective and efficient resource acquisition and deployment, in the midst of scarce resources, will bear positive fruits. Real problem-solving and economic recovery efforts according to the pundits are people centered thus, are not associated with white elephant projects.

According to them, the planned relocation of IMT to Owo, if it is true is a white elephant project.

Finally, the critical stakeholders listed in the paragraph above are here challenged to wade in and ask some critical questions. The fact is that, IMT Enugu is beyond the whims and caprices of few individuals and groups that are close to the Enugu State Government, who may rather than use the opportunity they have for public benefit.

 TO BE CONTINUED..

Thursday 5 October 2023

JUST IN: Plateau State Government Celebrated Nigeria’s 63rd Independence Anniversary Glamorously.

By: Reuben Egba,

Plateau State Government in a glamorous style Celebrated Nigeria’s 63rd Independence Anniversary on the 2nd October, 2023, at Rwang Pam Stadium Jos.

The mean event that marked the occasion was the march pass by the Nigerian Police and other Paramilitary, voluntary organizations.

There was also a marching competition by both the secondary and primary schools within Jos metropolitan.

At the start of the event, there was a heavy down pour, which ordinarily should have stopped the march pass, but evidently the participants came ready by refusing to leave the field, but continued with the event.

The Governor H.E. Barr. Caleb Mutfang, while taking the ceremonial salute, pleaded with students to leave the rain especially, the primary school children and they refused.

GOV. CALEB MUTFWANG

While delivering his speech, the Governor saluted the courage of the gallant Police parade that stood against all odds to see that the event is successful. Also and in same vein he appreciated other uniform organizations and students for standing with the Police parade to till the end of the marching exercise.

“It is indeed heartwarming to see this gathering this morning of dedicated men and women, who have come here this morning to reaffirm their faith and commitment to their great country Nigeria and I want to salute all of you that stood under the rains, to be able to make sure that, this occasion did not fail.

“I want to congratulate all of you particularly, those little children that defiled the weather and show the true Nigerian spirit that we can defile the odds and get this country working.

“I want to thank all of you, and I will like to appeal to everyone of us to copy from this men and women from these gallant children that, despite the odds we  face as a nation, we can summon all of them and make Nigeria rise to glory again.

“So on this hospitious occasion, I will like to congratulate all of us and I continue to urge all of us to have faith in our country, we have no other country to call our own except Nigeria, no matter how things have spoilt, where there is a will there is a way and together we can join hands to rebuild this nation.

“For us on the Plateau, I want to salute these men and women who have been posted on duty here in Plateau State, and I want to thank you sincerely the military formation and the paramilitary agencies for the contribution you are making daily and the sacrifices you are making daily to ensure that, the people of Plateau live in peace and by the Grace of God Plateau State shall know peace, your efforts will not go in vein”.

In appreciation to the commitment of those, who participated in the March Pass the Governor offered a cash reward, so that, after the rain especially the children, they can drink tea.

Wednesday 4 October 2023

PLATEAU: CRIMINAL SUMMONS: THE A-G AND THE PLATEAU STATE GOVERNMENT HAVE CHARGED, HON. JAN GOTIP, TO CHIEF MAGISTRATE COURT BOKKOS

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

Plateau State Government and the Attorney General of the state, have charged, Hon. Jang Gotip, to a Chief Magistrate Court of Plateau State sitting in Bokkos in Bokkos Local Government Area (LGA).

Plateau State Government and the Attorney General (A-G) of the state, in case No: CMCBK/CR132/2023, have filed “Form 2” of Criminal Summons against, Hon. Jan Gotip. REALITY can authoritatively state.

According to the court process sighted by REALITY, the Complainants (Plateau State Government and the Attorney General (A-G) of the state) have stated before the Court that, Hon. Jan is expected to answer a charge of offence(s) of Conspiracy, C/Trespass, H/breaking, Mischief, Theft, Thuggery, Incitement, Disturbance of Public Peace, C/Misappropriation, Rioting and Unlawful Assembly.

All, punishable under Sections: 59, 333, 336, 313, 272, 388, 78, 294, 77, 70 and 66 respectively of PSPC.

According to the Order of Court sighted and signed on 28th of September, 2023, the Chief Magistrate Court has further summoned, Hon. Jan Gotip, to personally appear in person before the court at Bokkos on the 5th of October, 2023, at about 9.00am to answer the said complaint against him.

TO BE CONTINUED..

Tuesday 3 October 2023

PLATEAU: BREAKING: INVESTIGATE HON. JUSTICE RITA IFIJEH IRELE’S GOVERNORSHIP TRIBUNAL. APC PETITIONS CJN, AS IT DESCRIBES PDP’S PETITION AS, “A CRASS DISPLAY OF MISCHIEF AND BAD BEHAVIOUR”

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

Like the Labour Party (LP) chapter in Plateau State, the All Progressives Congress (APC) has also reacted to the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) Plateau State chapter’s Petition sent to the National Judicial Council (NJC), signed by Hon. Chris Hassan, the State Chairman and Mr. John Akans the State PRO against the trio of Justice B.M. Tukur, Justice O. Elekwa and Justice A.O. Adetujoye who are Members of Panel One of the National/State Houses of Assembly Tribunal sitting in Jos, Plateau State.

In a press statement signed by, Miskoom Fidelis Longban, the State APC State Secretary and Hon. Sylvanus Namang, the State APC State Publicity Secretary, made available to REALITY, the party has described the Petition of the PDP as, “Crass display of mischief and bad behavior”.

The APC’s Petition addressed to HIS LORDSHIP, HON. JUSTICE OLUKAYODE ARIWOOLA, THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF NIGERIA & CHAIRMAN, NATIONAL JUDICIAL COUNCIL, ABUJA, in part stated that, “Our attention has been drawn to a petition emanating from the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), Plateau State Chapter, addressed to the National Judicial Council and signed by Hon. Chris Hassan, the State Chairman and Mr. John Akans the State PRO against the trio of Justice B.M. Tukur, Justice O. Elekwa and Justice A.O. Adetujoye, over their sound, meticulous and scrupulous judgments on the National and State Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal.

“In the petition, dated Monday, 25th September, 2023, they alleged “deliberate perversion of justice and conspiracy to remove our candidates from parliament.

“Although we are not holding brief for the three learned Justices, we are duty-bound to react to the said petition because of the insinuations which tend to portray our Party, the All Progressives Congress (APC) in bad light. We are not only greatly saddened by this crass display of mischief and bad behavior, but also feel disappointed with this development.

Suffice it to mention here that since the Governorship and National/State Assembly Election Petitions Tribunals began sitting in Jos, we have noticed how the People’s Democratic Party has continued to inundate the public and  social media space with all manners of physical threats, social media bullying as well as contemptuous and vile statements against the integrity of the highly respected Judges.

“We are not therefore, surprised that the PDP has come up with this mischievous petition!”

The APC’s Petition also urged the CJN to also investigate Members of the Governorship Panel that sat in the state.

“We also call for a thorough investigation of the hurriedly passed judgment of the Justice Rita Irele Ifijeh – led Gubernatorial Election Petition Tribunal in less than two hours without going into the merits of the petition by the APC and its gubernatorial candidate,  Dr Nentawe Yilwatda Goshwe.

As a law-abiding Party, we believe in the independence and sanctity of the judiciary to dispense justice justly and fairly hence our resort to appeal the judgments delivered against our candidates. The petition by the PDP against the eminent jurists against their unassailable judgments which we know will stand the test of time is absolutely in bad taste and should be discountenanced for what it really is, in terms of mischief and utter desperation”.

READ THE FULL TEXT BELOW:

3/10/2023

HIS LORDSHIP,

JUSTICE OLUKAYODE ARIWOOLA,

THE CHIEF JUSTICE OF NIGERIA & CHAIRMAN, NATIONAL JUDICIAL COUNCIL,

ABUJA.

YOUR LORDSHIP,

RE: PETITION AGAINST JUSTICES, B.M. TUKUR, O. ELEKWA AND A.O. ADETUJOYE BY THE PEOPLES DEMOCRATIC PARTY (PDP), PLATEAU STATE CHAPTER

Our attention has been drawn to a petition emanating from the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), Plateau State Chapter, addressed to the National Judicial Council and signed by Hon. Chris Hassan, the State Chairman and Mr. John Akans the State PRO against the trio of Justice B.M. Tukur, Justice O. Elekwa and Justice A.O. Adetujoye over their sound, meticulous and scrupulous judgments on the National and State Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal.

In the petition, dated Monday, 25th September, 2023, they alleged “deliberate perversion of justice and conspiracy to remove our candidates from parliament”.

Though we are not holding brief for the three learned Justices, we are duty-bound to react to the said petition because of the insinuations which tend to portray our Party, the All Progressives Congress, APC in bad light. We are not only greatly saddened by this crass display of mischief and bad behaviour but also feel disappointed with this development.

Suffice it to mention here that since the Governorship and National/State Assembly Election Petitions Tribunals began sitting in Jos, we have noticed how the People’s Democratic Party has continued to innundate the public and  social media space with all manners of physical threats, social media bullying as well as contemptuous and vile statements against the integrity of the highly respected Judges. We are not therefore, surprised that the PDP has come up with this mischievous petition!

In the said petition, they have particularly singled out the Justice B.M. Tukur-led National and State Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal One for frontal media assaults simply because it has stood on the part of justice while delivering its judgments, sacking some PDP candidates from office. One aspect of the judgments which not only vindicates our position and affirms the decision of Two Jos High Courts and the  Court of Appeal is the fact that the PDP in Plateau State does not only lack a valid structure for sponsoring candidates for election following its stubborn refusal to conduct an acceptable congress at the Wards, Local Government and State levels and is also in flagrant disobedience of several Court orders.

Furthermore, it is rather sad that in spite of the fact that section 285 (7) of the 1999 Constitution (as amended) provides for an appeal against any unsatisfactory decision of the Tribunal, the PDP has strangely resorted to its usual antics of blackmail through a so-called petition. This is even when the PDP, in a rather speculative manner, has not established any concrete grounds for such petition.

What we can readily decode here from the PDP’s body language is their ploy to unnecessarily harras and cajole the Judiciary into doing their bidding, as a pre-emptive move against impending verdicts of the Appeal Tribunal. To say the least, this action portrays a deliberate assault on democracy, independence of the Judiciary and the rule of law.

While we deprecate the use of foul and intemperate language against our Judges, in the course of discharging their constitutional mandate, we urge every party, no matter how aggrieved, to always explore the option of seeking redress at the appellate level instead of resorting to blackmail through uncomplimentary and uncharitable remarks against the hallowed temple of Justice.

We also call for a thorough investigation of the hurriedly passed judgment of the Justice Rita Irele Ifijeh – led Gubernatorial Election Petition Tribunal in less than two hours without going into the merits of the petition by the APC and its gubernatorial candidate,  Dr Nentawe Yilwatda Goshwe.

As a law-abiding Party, we believe in the independence and sanctity of the judiciary to dispense justice justly and fairly hence our resort to appeal the judgments delivered against our candidates. The petition by the PDP against the eminent jurists against their unassailable judgments which we know will stand the test of time is absolutely in bad taste and should be discountenanced for what it really is, in terms of mischief and utter desperation.

Finally, we humbly urge the National Judicial Council to ignore and disregard the said petition, considering its distractive shenanigans and lack of merit.

Signed:

MiskoomFidelis Longban,

APC State Secretary

Hon. Sylvanus Namang,

APC State Publicity Secretary

Monday 2 October 2023

PLATEAU: BREAKING: WHAT IS EVEN MORE PERPLEXING IS THAT, THE PDP THINKS THE NJC IS AN ARM OF THEIR UNORGANIZED POLITICAL PLATFORM--LABOUR PARTY (LP) REACTS

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

As the issues relating to the Judgments delivered by the Tribunal Panel Chaired by, Hon. Justice B. M. Tukur, continues to make the rounds and the Petition against the Members of the Panel also generating a fresh debate, the Labour Party Publicity Secretary in the State has descried he posture of the PDP in the matter as a, “DELIBERATE HYPOCRITICAL EFFORTS TO RIDICULE THE JUDICIARY WHEN TRIBUNAL JUDGEMENT IS NOT IN THEIR FAVOUR, BUT PRAISING SAME WHEN IT IS IN THEIR FAVOUR”.

READ THE FULL TEXT OF LABOUR PARTY BELOW:-

RE: PETITION AGAINST HON. JUSTICE B. M. TUKUR, HON. JUSTICE OMAKA ELEKWA AND HON. JUSTICE O. A. ADETUJOYE FOR DELIBERATE PERVERSION OF JUSTICE AND CONSPIRACY TO REMOVE CANDIDATES OF OUR PARTY ELECTED TO PARLIAMENT.

It is with utter amazement that the PDP in Plateau State has taken its gross disrespect for constituted authority to another level. This time around, the purported Chairman and Secretary of the Party in the State have written a petition dated 25th September, 2023, to the National Judicial Council (NJC) against the judges that presided on the National and State Assembly Election Petition led by Hon. Justice B. M. Tukur, and shared the said petition on social media platforms to whip sentiments.

What is even more perplexing is that PDP in Plateau State think that the NJC is another arm of their unorganized political platform. You could see clearly that the petition is a complete display of ignorance of the workings of the judicial arm of government. Indeed, they intend to drag the judiciary into their political shenanigans by politicizing cases legitimately decided by judges of the tribunal who discharged their duties dispassionately.

Firstly, it is expedient to note that the Hon. Justices being petitioned, worked with the facts and documents presented before them by the petitioners, especially the binding decisions of the Court of Appeal against PDP in Plateau State as lately as 28th October, 2022. The Tribunal was bound by the principle of Judicial Precedence/stare decisis and the doctrine of issue Estoppel.

One is forced to wonder why the same PDP did not petition the Justices of both the Tribunal and Court of Appeal that decided the cases of Musa Agah and Peter Dasat. Of course, they raised the issue of their purported congress of 25th September, 2021 in those cases. But both the tribunal and court of appeal held that they had not yet complied with the order of justice Gang. The Court of Appeal held in Musa Agah’s case, thus:

“it is important to point out at this stage that the Appellants have a misconception of this issue. This issue is not whether the 2nd Appellant was screened and cleared to contest the election to have satisfied all the requirements of the law. The issue in controversy with regard to non-qualification of the 2nd Appellant to contest the bye election of 26th February, 2022 relates to an order of court of competent jurisdiction, the High Court of Plateau State directing the 1st Appellant to conduct election for the PDP Executive Committee Members of Plateau State… the Appellants’ Counsel has a misconception when he argued that the matter is a pre-election matter… it follows therefore, that the 1st Appellant has no structure in existence to sponsor the 2nd Appellants for the bye election.. for failure to comply with the order of State High Court in Suit No. PLD/J304/2020…”

The above decision was delivered on 28th October, 2022.

The salient questions that come to mind are:

Why didn’t PDP petition the Justices in Musa Agah and those of Peter Dasat’s cases?

After the judgements of the Appellate Court in October, 2022, did the PDP take steps to comply with the order of court?

Is PDP not still relying on the purported congress of 25th September, 2021 which was dismissed by the Court of Appeal in 2022?

What has changed from 28th October, 2022 when the Court of Appeal gave its judgment, to the time of this last General Election?

By the way, the submission of PDP in their petition clearly shows an intention to blackmail the judiciary simply because they lost some of their cases at the tribunal. That a decision goes against you does not mean that the judges perverted justice. Justice does not mean the decision must be in your favour. In fact, to even berate the judiciary for giving judgment against you is in itself, perversion of justice.

Thankfully, the NJC is not a political department of the PDP to consider issues from emotional or political standpoints. The NJC knows better than to be dragged into this political gimmick the PDP in Plateau State is playing.

Lastly, in that feeble and uncoordinated petition of the PDP, they failed to understand that the electoral process does not start and end at the general polls. An error at the preliminary stage of the process could turn out to be brutally fatal later. No wonder, they took for granted the consistent insistence of the court that they do the right thing. They cannot now be heard to be crying foul.

The NJC should therefore, disregard the said petition as same is misconceived and ill-intended. Their attempt to gag the judiciary must fail woefully.

HON. JAMES ADARA AWARA

(Labour Party Publicity Secretary, Plateau State)

Sunday 1 October 2023

PLATEAU POLITICS: IS PDP SHOPPING FOR ENEMIES? PUNDITS ASK

By: Valentine Adese (JP),

Since the beginning of the Legal Processes in the 2023 general election, members of the Plateau State chapter of the Peoples Democratic Party (PDP), seem to be shopping for a possible enemy of the party in the state and without, with the aim of accusing them for been part of the problem of the party and the state.

The party members and its officials in the state, have been accused by pundits in the state on the ground hat, rather than looking inwards to challenge and correct any perceived irregularities within the members and their officials have rather, decided to expend their energies to be listing to perceived enemy voices and write ups, on radio programs and on the social media respectively.

It is a fact that, all the people that voted in the governorship election in Plateau State on the 18th of March, 2023, are citizens of Nigeria, with some being indigenous to the state.

At the end of the election exercise, the Returning Officer for the governorship election in the state and Vice Chancellor, Federal University, Lafia, Professor Idris Amali, declared the PDP candidate winner at exactly 3:33 on Monday afternoon after collating results from the 17 local government areas of the state.

You would recall that, the PDP had been in power in Plateau State since 1999 until 2015, when the APC candidate, Simon Lalong, dislodged the party and won the governorship election of the state.

Also, Governor Lalong had won his re-election in 2019 to retain power for the APC before a fresh governorship election took place on Saturday, 18th March, 2023.

All through this period under review, while the PDP remained in opposition, the APC had no course to start searching or shopping for enemies.

Facts are that, the APC only constantly reply to constructive criticism from the PDP in the media space.

It is also a fact that, the PDP’s candidate, Mutfwang, was declared as the duly elected governor at the INEC collation center in Jos,  by the state Returning Officer saying that, the PDP candidate polled 525,299 votes to defeat his closest rival and the candidate of the ruling APC as it were then, Dr. Nentawe Yilwatda, who polled 481,370 votes.

It is on record that, after this declaration, the APC and its candidate did not indulge in name calling and delving into spiritual suspicions of INEC officials. They simply headed to the Tribunal, which is the next phase of the election process for 2023 general election.

There is also the need to know that, one of its members, who once headed PDP’s Legal Team, both in the rescue of the party and one of its Leaders, Sen. Da Jonah David Jang, from the hands of the EFCC and ICPC, Hon. Edward Pwajok (SAN), was tagged an enemy of the party for simply advising the chapter to obey instant Court Orders.

It is on record that, the Governorship election results showed as at then that, the PDP candidate, Caleb Mutfwang, won 7 out of 13 LGAs as published on’ March 19, 2023, while the APC candidate led in Shendam, Kanke, Pankshin, Kanam, Jos East and Wase Local Governments.

The question here is, can these people become part of the enemies been searched for by the PDP members? Pundits are asking.

As the panel of the National/State Houses of Assembly Election Petitions Tribunal chaired by Hon. Justice B. M. Tukur started dishing out Judgments not in favaour of the PDP, another potion of hell’s gate was opened against the Panel Members. This time, they are tagged “Enemy of Plateau State” going by the petition filed against them to the NJC by PDP EXCO led by its State Chairman, Hon. Chris Hassan.

Although they are not forced to respond, the Panel Members have advised the Lawyers having cases before them to look inwards and advise their clients.

The members have also admonished the Lawyers to always tell their clients the truth of what happens at the Tribunal and speak to them in the language they would understand.

According to them, “The person who bought you today will not trust you tomorrow!”

However, it must be noted that, it was as a result of the sheer number of Election Petition cases in Nigeria this year and the desire to ensure that all cases are completed within 180 days (6 months) as required by Section 285(6) of the 1999 constitution, that the Chief Justice of Nigeria created one Tribunal, but with separate Panels to dispose of the cases within the time required by the Constitution.

In Plateau state as in other states with many cases, the Tribunal has three (3) Panels thus:-

  1. Governorship Panel Cases
  2. Legislative Houses Cases-the Legislative Houses Panel is further subdivided into Panel A and Panel B

Because of the sheer number of cases that came up for Senate, House of Representatives and State.

In its verdicts for the State Assembly petitions, the same Tribunal has also declared the following APC candidates as winners: Rt. Hon. Yakubu Sanda for Pengana constituency; Hon. Eli Bako Ankala for Rukuba/ Irigwe constituency; Hon. Sylvester Ibrahim Wallangko for Bokkos constituency;  Hon. Nanbol Josiah Gomam for Langtang North-Central constituency; Hon. Mark Sunday Naah for Jos North-West constituency and Hon. Dachung Moses for Riyom constituency.

By implication, the APC now controls the majority in the State Legislature with the following spread as it stands: APC 14; PDP 9 and YPP 1.

For the National Assembly, the APC now has 2 Senators and 4 Members House of Representatives against the PDP’s 1 Senator and 2 Members House of Representatives whereas the LP has 2 Members House of Representatives.

TO BE CONTINUED….